Refinish or replace?
Refinishing a solid floor usually costs a fraction of replacing it and takes days, not weeks. Here is when replacing makes more sense.
Refinish when
- The floor is solid wood, or engineered with a thick enough top layer.
- The damage is on the surface: scratches, worn finish, dents, a color you are tired of.
- Damaged areas are small enough to replace board by board.
Replace when
- The floor has been sanded so often that the tongue or nails show across large areas.
- It is engineered and the top layer is gone or too thin.
- Water has damaged the subfloor, or large areas are buckled.
- You want a different floor altogether: a wider board, a different species, a different look.
When it is close, ask a pro to look at both. A good one will tell you if refinishing is not worth it.
Ready for a real answer about your floor?